What leverage is
Leverage means buying with the bank's money. If the flat earns more than the loan costs, the difference is yours, and the appreciation is on the whole flat, not just on what you put in. In the example, buying outright you put in €168,850 and the IRR is 6.6%; with 80% financed you put in €56,850 and the IRR rises to 11.5%.
Why does the first year return less? The payment has two parts. The interest is a cost; the rest repays the loan, and that money is not lost: every month you own a little more of the flat outright. The first-year return on the cash you put in only sees the money leaving your pocket; the IRR sees everything.
What happens if interest rates rise
With a 80% mortgage, every point of interest shows in the payment and the cash flow (see the table alongside). For this flat, the mortgage stops paying for itself at an interest rate of 6.8%: above that, you would be topping it up every month.
If your mortgage is variable, try the calculator with the rate one or two points higher. If the flat still pays for itself, you have a margin.
How much a bank will lend on an investment flat
For a home you will not live in, Spanish banks usually lend less than for your main home: typically 60% to 70% of the value (the lower of the valuation and the purchase price), and 80% only with a strong profile or extra guarantees. They also ask that all your debt payments stay below 30–35% of your income.
The deposit and all the purchase costs come from you: in the example, with 80% financed, that is €56,850 between deposit, taxes, notary, land registry, refurbishment and furniture.
The mortgage in rental income tax
Mortgage interest and costs are deducted from your rental income for income tax, together with property tax, service charges, insurance and depreciation. The part of the payment that repays the loan is not deducted. Interest and repairs together cannot exceed the rent collected in the year: the excess can be deducted over the following four years.
The calculator already does this. That is why, with a bigger mortgage, you pay less income tax on the rent.
The risk: how long it can sit empty
More mortgage means less margin. Bought outright, this flat covers its costs even if it is only let 16% of the year; with 80% financed it needs to be let 74% of the year, and with 90%, 81%. Keep a cushion for several months of payments.